This question was asked by Little Grapefruit, at the end of her imagined year as Bill Drummond. It is number 15 of the 23 Questions.
We have three answers here, by Gaynor, Christine and Jane. We also have some examples of melodies as selected during the proceedings of a recent GANTOB committee, reported back by Little Grapefruit. Thank you to all involved in the production of number 46 of the 52 pamphlets.
If you have an idea for a pamphlet, please don’t be alarmed that we are coming close to number 52. We may need to go over that number, in which case we can do some shuggling about for the final book to keep the totals tight. As long as we have your submission by 23:23 (GMT) on 30 June 2024 your entry will be considered. The same applies to answers to the 23 Questions (ideally focussing on the as yet unanswered questions). Email your submissions to mailto:100percentvinyl2@gmail.com.
MY MELODIC LIFE/ MANTRA (by GAYNOR)
What is melodic? Life is always twist and turns, up and downs. How do we know we are alive without them?
This is my melodic fall back when I can’t see in front of me, when I need reminding who the hell I am (and to get a grip).
She’ll carry on through it all, she’s a waterfall
And I do. I’m quite famed for this
I carry on through life
Resilient to the core
Raising my brigantine sails
My stormy melodic life
Rushing water always finds a way to join the big calm pool
Crashing over moss and rocks and vertical drops
She’ll carry on through it all….
My song of my melodic life thanks to the Stone Roses’ Waterfall
GAYNOR 29 May 2024

MELODIC? (by CHRISTINE)
The question was asked by Little Grapefruit. Little Grapefruit is melodic. Bounces about making mad observations about the world, from his perspective way down there, when all he can do is bob. One day he bobbed off, went across the sea. And his cousin Angharad, she bobbed along to see him. She was also melodic. She bounced around Liverpool, making noises and squishes and squashes and rolling down steps in a very melodic way.
Then along came Christine who had to tell us all about Little Grapefruit’s Welsh cousin Angharad. And she does so in a melodic voice wouldn’t you say? There’s something about her voice. Maybe it’s because she’s a Scouser. She hasn’t lived there for thirty years, but still she’s got the melodic way going on in her voice, just the way most Scousers have. Or at least the nice ones. The cranky ones don’t seem to have the melody going on: they bark a bit more. But nice Scousers, they don’t. They jump around in their trabs. Maybe that’s what makes them melodic, because their trabs are so bouncy, so their voice bounces as they talk too. I don’t know, because even when I wear boots I’m still melodic.
So what is melodic. It’s something that sounds nice, that’s for sure. Something that flows, bounces, beats, jumps, breaks. A break’s melodic. I love breaks. I’m a junglist. I love jungle. That’s very melodic. It’s better than that old dance music that you used to get in the 90s, 80s rather. 80s/90s. Sometimes we banded them together didn’t we, in the books, you know, and the puzzles? It was always 80s/90s. But there was a difference between the 80s and 90s. Because the 80s was a bit like “doo do doo do doo”. And the 90s was more “boo boo boo”. Very melodic.
I like melodies. We can sing along to a melody. Let’s make a melody about Little Grapefruit.
“Oh Little Grapefruit,
You’re very bouncy”.
That wasn’t good was it?
It’s the best I could do.
I’m still in bed.
I was up at 5. Up at 7. Up at 9. But half 10 I’m back in bed. That’s melodic. That’s definitely got a bounce to it.
I’ve been to my polytunnel twice. That’s not very melodic, apart from when the wind blows.
But outside the polytunnel, the birds sing. That’s melodic. Apart from Pedro the peacock. He’s not very melodic. Nah. He just goes “pkwaaah, pekkkha”. Nothing melodic about that. But the robins, and all the other birds, that go tweet, there’s definitely melody in there. It’s nice. I love it.
Some say police cars and sirens are melodic. But I really don’t miss them, not since I lived in the countryside. I haven’t heard one in years, not in my own home. I’ve heard them when I’ve gone out places, but not here. The only melody we get here is birds.
CHRISTINE 30 May 2024

JURA MELODIES (by JANE)
50 commoners singing to the sea.
Sand crunches, waves lap, swallows scream;
scratching of midge bites, sipping of whisky.
Four hands clapping from a passing boat.
Cough cough cough
Rat tat tat
George types 1984.
Down in the boathouse banknotes crackle.
JANE 1 June 2024




A GANTOB (committee) MEDLEY
Little Grapefruit was listening in to the meeting of the GANTOB Legacy Committee. The Benefaktor was chairing. Hiding under a couple of Braeburn apples and a wrapped quarter of watermelon, and nestled in beside a family of kiwis and an unwashed beetroot that had been placed in the fruit bowl in a rush to empty the shopping trolley for its next trip, she was unobserved by the humans. She could hear Urs and Katie in the room, at least two voices that she did not recognise, and Gillian joining in on Zoom.
Over a scheduled break from the tedium of yet another meeting, they were comparing notes on favourite music. Urs was commenting on the tingly anticipation of hearing a favourite piece unexpectedly on the radio – the opening bars, the recognition, dropping everything to listen attentively, shushing everybody else, concentrating, immersing oneself, the build to the release of the first line of the vast chorus singing out in the Usher Hall, Albert Hall or Westminster Abbey. She is talking about the opening bars of Handel’s Zadok the Priest. Not that she is a royalist. She is at pains to point that out. Once the second line has been sung, Nathan the prophet is announced, and the SATB are fully in their stride, the job has been done – Urs will be back doing her accounts, the dishes or tending to her cuttings. That is a tune, even if it only uses a couple of notes.
The Benefaktor is dismissive of this. Why on earth make do with music that fills you up before it has really even begun. He prefers a piece that takes you right up to the end, leaving you wanting more. He connects his phone to his Cambridge Audio network player and insists that everybody sits in total silence for the next 11 minutes 27 seconds. He does not announce the piece. It is, he explains, a guilty pleasure. Not something that you hear on BBC Radio 3. It starts with guitar arpeggios. A bassline comes in like footsteps. Little Grapefruit likes the first line, which is about going out without your shoes on. She doesn’t wear shoes. The singer is thinking big – the whole world, the purpose of music, other existential thoughts. There are chords that bleed into the next line, the B flat lingering into the C major, reinforcing the interconnectedness of it all. Sweeping strings, and then a tempo change, each section full of simplicity and wonder, a climax, then a sense of waves breaking against the rocks of emotion and loss. A jump to Brazil, smiles, sun, drum rolls of anticipation, religion and mind altering substances. And the final scene change, back to the original theme, “stay together”, “sing together”, “all feel the benefit”, concluding with a guitar solo that lasts over two minutes and stops without warning, just when Little Grapefruit thinks that she could surf these chords for ever. She is left with an aftertaste of feelings that she does not really understand. A smorgasbord of elation, sadness, longing and love. Like the bittersweetness of a grapefruit. The Benefaktor has raised his hand, demanding several seconds of silence before they can move on.
Katie, The Foundation Doktor, is up next. Little Grapefruit knows that she is smarting from a recent breakup. Dr K has gone back to 1975 (year not the band), and a John Cale track called “I Keep A Close Watch”. She listens to at least one of the various versions (or covers) every day at the moment. This version – the Cale original – opens with piano and swooning strings, then some brass and a slide guitar. Against this beautiful melody, Cale’s voice is flat (emotionally). It’s perfect for the piece. He sounds broken. At the line “I still hear your voice at night” Katie sobs into her hoodie sleeve, but stays sitting, waiting out the end of the song. She doesn’t have to wait very long. All too quickly it’s into a repeated chorus and slide guitar. Done and dusted in under three and a half minutes. TFD leaves the room as her grandfather starts deliberating on the track. “Leaves you wanting more – willing a return to the original theme”. But Little Grapefruit is not listening. She’s back to that chopping board, attempting to separate beauty from sadness.
Gillian is up next. She has chosen a more recent track – Emmy the Great’s Trellick Tower – and explains before The Benefaktor starts playing the track on her behalf, that she does not relate the lyrics to her personal circumstances. She just loves the song. And Ali has given up religion. He is a crofter now. Little Grapefruit listens in carefully. A simple piano line, the vulnerability of the voice, the bass. The Benefaktor begins to interrupt at the lyric “Been burying the books you left”, but Urs stops him. There’s an optimistic leap of a key change – from C major to F major, and then the explanation for that lift in spirits: “trying to keep you”. Urs hurries out at the mention of a “Relic of a love gone by”. Little Grapefruit sits absolutely still for the final 10 seconds as the sustained piano fades to nothing.
Last up, it’s one of the voices that Little Grapefruit didn’t know. The Benefaktor is being a smart aleck: “So _______” (it’s a name or word that LG doesn’t know and can’t pronounce), “be frank with us. Has any song earned your stamp of approval?”
After a rather dusty conversation between these two older men, The Benefaktor puts Big Star’s 1978 song Holocaust on the HiFi. Little Grapefruit listens attentively, shivering up against the bristly skins of the kiwis. She is terrified. She pokes one of the apples to shift a little bit and let some light in. Alex Chilton starts singing, his broken whisper of a voice, so vulnerable, after a haunting introduction of piano, cello, slide guitar and acoustic bass. A choir joins in. Little Grapefruit realises, despite her experience of such things, that this is a song about loss. She is not sure whose loss. There’s an intimacy: “You’re sitting down to dress”. Frailty. Bereavement. Ambiguity. Bile: “You’re a wasted face, You’re a sad-eyed lie”. The instruments howl out the last of their melody.
And with that The Benefaktor slaps the table and calls through to Urs and Katie. “That’s more than enough time”, he shouts. The spell is broken. The GANTOB Legacy Committee is reconvened. There is mention of broadening horizons beyond The KLF. Little Grapefruit is not listening. She is reliving the dozens of melodies captured in these four songs, all memorable in their own right, tugging at the heart strings, beautiful despite desolation, or cresting on the power of carefully selected chords as if taking flight. The kiwis, however, have heard none of it. They have a different idea of melody. They have their headphones on, plugged into Taylor Swift’s biggest hits, looking forward to her concert at Murrayfield that night. Each to their own.
LITTLE GRAPEFRUIT 8 June 2024
#GANTOB2024 number 46/ 52 pamphlets































